Public Policy

Resign or Reform: Preserving Institutional Integrity at the Election Commission

17 November 2026

Resign or Reform: Preserving Institutional Integrity at the Election Commission

Can a trust in Election commission can be upholded by removing the CEC ?? Recent controversy erupted on CEC removal due to allegation against him for Unilateral decision making. Now the real question arises is whether the change in leadership, change in law or both are needed for better governance of our country.

The controversy : who decides within Election commission

On September 23 2026 the Indian Express reported that two election commissioners had recorded objection 14 times in 10 months. This report shows that the decision made were not based on consensus and proper consultation has not happened between three member commission.

The Election commission is a Constitutional institution under article 324 who is responsible for conducting free and fair election. Its credibility can be maintained if it follows transparent procedure and meaningful deliberation. Thus the disagreement among commissioner is in itself is not unlawful rather analyzation should happen whether objection received appropriate consideration or not.

Resignation or Removal ; what is the constitutional route?

Currently Public protest is demanding removal of CEC But according to the law CEC can be removed by following same procedure for Supreme court judge removal under article 324(5). So through protest they can try to ensure accountability but the resignation requires a procedure that to be followed. This procedure involves parliamentary removal process requiring special majority in both house of the parliament.

Meanwhile, other Election commissioners can be removed after the recommendation of CEC. This process is important to make election authority to work without fear of removal. Thus the policy challenge is to establish accountability without weakening the constitutional protection that allows commission to work independently.

Reforming the system : Three Practical steps

Policymakers should examine these steps to maintain institutional integrity,

First, Equal Protection for Election Commissioners: Extend removal protection to Election Commissioners on par with the CEC to enable independent decision-making and fearless dissent.

Second Clear Transaction of Business Rules: Codify internal procedures requiring circulation and approval of major decisions by all Commissioners, strengthening collegial decision-making, transparency and accountability.

Third, Bar Post-Retirement Government Roles: Introduce a cooling-off period or restrictions on post-retirement executive appointments to reduce perceptions of conflicts of interest or quid pro quo.

Conclusion

The ECI is central to ensuring free and fair elections. Strengthening its structural autonomy, financial independence, collegial transparency and institutional integrity is essential to preserve the “perception of independence” and sustain public confidence in India’s electoral process.

Question

Evaluating the current vulnerabilities in the appointment and tenure of Election Commissioners, what multi-pronged reform framework would best secure the ECI’s functional autonomy from the executive?

Sources

Comments

Your comment

Sign in to join in

Sign in to like this and join the conversation.

Continue reading

  • PERILS OF PANCHAYAT PROXIES
    Public Policy

    PERILS OF PANCHAYAT PROXIES

    2 November 2026

    Representation of women in local governance and how it is continued to getting hampered despite laws and amendments in place.

  • SIR and the Long Continuous Battle Surrounding it
    Public Policy

    SIR and the Long Continuous Battle Surrounding it

    11 October 2026

    India’s Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has intensified debates over voter eligibility, democratic participation and the risk of wrongful exclusion. From women and transgender persons to religious minorities, the exercise raises urgent questions about electoral transparency, accountability and safeguards.